Our political paralysis on data centers could soon lead to disaster

By Gary Abernathy

One of the most common reactions following an election defeat is to capitulate to the winning message on the other side even when it was entirely misleading or just plain wrong. 

That seems to be the thinking of Republican Senator Josh Hawley (Mo.), who saw his party fall victim to millions of dollars in attack ads that lied to voters about the perils of data centers. In turn, Hawley is now advocating for Congress to pass a nationwide moratorium on data centers, putting him in the same unlikely company as Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), not to mention Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-Mich.).

Despite data centers being successfully weaponized for campaign purposes, common-sense Republicans refused to disavow them, although some promised stricter oversight and more guarantees from developers. But to join the calls for a moratorium is to ignore reality – not to mention the smarter approach by our neighbors to the north. 

While some U.S. politicians are quaking in fear over the blowback to data center development, Canada is welcoming them with open arms. Led by Prime Minister Mark Carney, Canada is doing exactly what the U.S. should have done long ago – establishing clear AI policy guidelines, including parameters for the construction of data centers, and inviting the biggest players in the industry to sign up and get to work. 

 The Canadian guidelines describe data centers as “critical infrastructure” that supports health care, financial services, research and secure government systems, as reported by the New York Sun, with an invitation “for the world’s leading technology companies to invest in Canada.” The document is designed to ensure that “Canada becomes the premier destination for the next generation of global AI infrastructure.”

To be sure, the U.S. should not entirely emulate Canada’s data center policy, since it emphasizes the use of “renewables” as opposed to promoting the most affordable, abundant and reliable energy sources. But the mere fact that the country had the foresight to create a policy and recruit developers puts it a giant step ahead of its southern neighbor. 

It’s worth noting that even in Canada, with its lip service to “green, clean energy,” a new Meta data center – a $9 billion AI-optimized campus in Alberta – “will be powered by a dedicated new natural gas plant,” according to the Sun. That’s how reality works. 

As the Sun story notes, Alberta is often compared to Texas, but “ambitious plans to build out centers in the Lone Star state have been cast in doubt by Tuesday’s midterm elections, which put a skeptical new Democratic administration in the state capital.”

So while Hawley and the new Democrat/Socialist regime that is taking hold in the U.S. want to tell data centers to slow their roll, we’ll be allowing Canada, China and other countries to develop and control AI and craft the rules that govern it? Not smart.

 The utter nonsense of the backlash against data centers was recently spelled out in compelling detail by Charles C.W. Cooke in a National Review essay. As Cooke notes, “In 2026, data centers are such an inextricable part of American life that to discuss whether they are welcome is the equivalent of agonizing over what we think of this newfangled ‘television’ thing.”

Cooke lists numerous ways in which Americans rely on data centers every day. He points out that while the notion of information residing on “the cloud” has taken root, “there is no such thing. There are just data centers and the computers that run inside them. … Each one of the 5,427 data centers in the United States is a real place, full of rows of real machines, that run on real electricity, and that are maintained by real people. Your data — by which I mean your emails, your bank account, your business files, your photographs of your kids — are sitting somewhere on a realhard disk.”

In the wake of the midterm results, it’s easy to imagine other Republicans joining Hawley in the demonization of data centers in a misguided effort to curry favor with the public. They would do well to reflect on the pages of history that are filled with examples of fearful naysayers trying to prevent progress on developments that today are considered indispensable. The task at hand is not to cater to the prevailing sentiment, but instead to responsibly enlighten the public with the facts. 

Just last week, a nationwide air traffic ground stop served as a stark warning about the consequences of delaying technological modernization. A moratorium on data centers would soon result in more catastrophes. The degree to which our lives have become dependent on even the most basic AI technology might only be fully realized when it collapses due to our political paralysis. 

Change is always met with resistance, and sometimes the admonition to tread carefully is good advice. But treading carefully does not mean standing still. We cannot stop the development of data centers; they will either be built here or somewhere else. It would be a shame if the only way to bring common sense to our approach to data centers in the U.S. was to make Canada our 51st state after all.  

Gary Abernathy is a longtime newspaper editor, reporter and columnist. He was a contributing columnist for the Washington Post from 2017-2023 and a frequent guest analyst across numerous media platforms.

Paid for by The Empowerment Alliance